Best Witch Hazel Aftershave

Artisan Shaving is reader-supported. We may earn a commission from links on this page.

The best witch hazel aftershave. Finding it can be the ticket to ending your post-shave problems.

If you have ever found you struggle with shaving rash, razor bumps or any other irritation as a result of shaving, there’s a good chance that using witch hazel as aftershave will help.

Witch hazel is a natural anti-inflammatory and astringent – meaning it tightens the skin and removes blemishes. It’s also full of tannins which can help heal the skin.

That said, its not so great for stopping bleeding from shaving cuts as it’s often advertised to be. It may help close a cut but does not contribute to the blood clotting like a anti-hemorrhagic such as a styptic pencil.

So overall witch hazel after shaving is a great way to calm the skin down and reduce any redness and soreness but might not be the best cure for shaving cuts.

Like most post-shave treatments witch hazel can be found in various forms. Alcohol-based splashes are more traditional while aftershave balms can be more gentle on the skin. Generally if you’re looking for the best witch hazel aftershave then you are probably keen on gentle natural remedies rather than more aggressive alcohol splashes. In particular you should pay attention to just how much witch hazel extract is in a product in order to judge whether it suits your needs.

Lucky Tiger Aftershave

Lucky Tiger is a fairly traditional aftershave splash but its alcohol free and features a healthy dose of witch hazel and aloe vera among other soothing ingredients like sage leaf and green tea. Because of this low-impact formula for sensitive skin it does not have much scent – as pungent fragrance oils can cause reactions and irritation – but does have a very gentle citrus aroma.

Thayers Alcohol-Free Original Witch Hazel Facial Toner with Aloe Vera Formula , clear , 12 oz

Thayers’ natural remedies are an empire built entirely on witch hazel with a range of high quality witch hazel products. A classic brand, Thayers dates back to a 1847 and now specializes in cruelty-free, certified-organic skincare remedies.

Their proprietary extract contains 195% more tannins than similar brands and the tonic itself is enhanced with aloe vera. They achieve a higher concentration of natural beneficial ingredients and antioxidants using an extraction method that avoids the standard method of distilling the witch hazel.

Humphrey’s Witch Hazel Astringent 100% All Natural Witch Hazel 16 Ounce

Humphrey’s is another classic brand that’s centuries old – so its no surprise their witch hazel comes in this beautiful bottle. Note that Humphrey’s does contain 14% alcohol. While that’s nothing compared to a traditional aftershave splash, you may want to stick with Thayers if you are looking to avoid alcohol. Alcohol can also contribute to dry skin. There is also a lot of debate online about its organic qualities so if this matters to you it might be one to avoid.

Win a Merkur Futur Worth $60!

Merkur Futur Review