Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin

Artisan Shaving is reader-supported. We may earn a commission from links on this page.

When it comes to getting a close and comfortable shave, you must consider choosing some good cream for shaving. It will not only prepare to your skin for the first contact with the razor, but will also protect it from possible razor burns and cuts. That’s how important it is to choose right kind of shave cream.

Things become even more complicated if you have overly sensitive skin. In this case, you have very little to no room for error. Any experiments with cheap canned beard lubes may bring you long-lasting discomfort . Even the best safety razor and the sharpest blade become of little use without a quality shave cream.

Shave lubes come in many different varieties including soaps, creams, gels, and more. For the purpose of this article, we shall have a look at six of the best shaving creams that you can currently purchase online. You’ll quickly find out that the traditional creams are a whole lot better than the mass-marketed shaving lubes that you may find in the nearest grocery or drug store.

Instead of cheap fillers and generic substitutes, they are made of high-quality ingredients. As a result, the consistency of these creams is nice and lathery. When used with a quality razor blade, they change the routine of shaving into a sensual and pleasant moment that your sensitive skin will rejoice.

1.Jack Black Triple Cushion

Unlike Taylor of Old Bond Street that has been on the market for a century and a half, Jack Black (review) is a much newer addition to men’s grooming menagerie. This new brand has build its marketing strategy around the provision of eco-conscious shaving solution for individuals with sensitive skin. 

Because it’s very light, you don’t need a brush to apply this product onto your face. This is especially convenient for men and women who are frequently on the go. To them, Jack black offers a wide variety of skin care products that will make their skin look fresh and energized. It goes without saying that their beard lube works wonders for men with sensitive skin.

Jack Black Triple Cushion uses a special selection of fine natural ingredients, so that men and ladies with sensitive skin should experience almost no adverse or side effects when using it. These ingredients include jojoba oil, heather extract, macadamia seed oil, peppermint oil, etc.

The one ingredient that has earned this product the largest number of positive reviews is the Cetostearyl alcohol. Unlike simple alcohols, Cetostearyl alcohol is of fatty nature. This means that Jack Black Triple Cushion delivers an additional layer of protection on your skin.


  • Contains all-natural products that provide maximum comfort
  • No need for a shave brush
  • Provides excellent glide even on sensitive skin


  • A bit pricey compared to other similar products
  • Users have reported issues with the container of the product
  • Some users find it just too thick and lathery for their skin

2.The Art Of Shaving Unscented Beard Lube

The Art of Shaving’s products are not as affordable as a tube or some mainstream shave gel. They sell in supermarkets, drugstores and gas stations across the USA. Although it is widely accessible, this unscented beard lube has earned a spot among the best shaving creams out there!

This product is your perfect insurance against any post-shave issues, especially if you have sensitive skin. It surely costs a bit more than a box of cheap shaver cream that you can find in the convenience store behind the corner. Some research reveals that the Taylor of Old Bond Street shave lube costs about $3.20 per ounce while The Art of Shaving’s product is around $5.00 per ounce. 

If you are looking for some truly exceptional comfort regardless of the cost, give this shave cream a try. Except for the high price, The Art of Shaving’s product is highly revered among men and women with sensitive skin, because of its unique formula based on a special mixture of glycerin and coconut acid. It guarantees that your face feels smooth and irritation-free after every shave.

So, if you have chronic skin problems and you don’t have to make them worse with razor burns and cuts, this shave cream can very well help remedy the situation. Brethren with super sensitive skin, this shave cream is for you! Just be ready to pay the price for this otherworldly comfort.


  • Can be used with or without brush 
  • The glycerin and coconut base provides supreme skin comfort
  • With this lube, a razor burn becomes a thing of the past


  • The price may turn you down
  • Users have complained that the jar is too big to fit inside most bathroom vanity mirror cabinets
  • The content of the box is in fluid ounces

3.Proraso Sensitive Skin Shave Cream

If you have extremely sensitive skin, this is going to be your perfect wet shaving companion. The Italians know a thing or two about wet shaving, and Proraso (review) is their finest solution for sensitive skin. Like Taylor of Old Bond Street, Proraso has been around since 1908.

Their product range caters to wet shavers with several different skin types including those that get razor bumps, razor burn, and ingrown hairs rather easily.

Their white label product line has got a special formula to take exceptional care of even the most sensitive skin. Proraso’s beard lube comes as a traditional shave cream and a shave soap, so the wet shaver can choose whichever suits them better.

As a rule cream is easier to work with, and it is therefore more suitable for novices. It easily generates a rich lather with very little effort. Shaving soaps, on the other hand, are for experienced professionals. So, what makes the Proraso white label line stand out in the crowd?

The answer is in their two key ingredients: oatmeal extract and green tea. When these two get together, they acquire mighty anti-oxidant qualities and protect the skin from wandering free radicals. Our third choice also has a post-shave soothing effect that eliminates the risk of razor bumps and ingrown hairs. Men with medium to highly sensitive skin will be very pleased with this shave cream.

If you are looking for a more traditional European brand that has withstood the test of time, Proraso is your fine choice! Even though this shave cream comes in a tube not a box, it still requires a shave brush for a proper distribution on your face.


  • One of the best choices for individuals with sensitive skin 
  • Offered in both cream and soap form
  • Perfect for dry skin


  • Both cream and soap variants do require a brush for optimal distribution
  • Not suitable for oily skin types
  • Users complain of overwhelming menthol smell when creating the lather

4.Taylor of Old Bond Street – Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin

This is an affordable and highly-rated shave cream that works wonders for even the most sensitive skin. The company’s secret is their minimalist approach to ingredients (just aloe, jojoba, and glycerin), as well as the lack of any parabens or artificial fragrances.

As mentioned on several occasions above, Taylor of Old Bond Street has got long-established traditions in wet shaving. Their creams for sensitive skin provide a slick lubricated base. Taylor of Old Bond Street needs a shave brush so as to develop its full potential.

Some wet shavers may try using their hands instead of a shave brush, but we don’t recommend this, as you’ll miss out on this product’s best qualities. Application aside, the very nature of this shave cream guarantees a soft lathery base that helps your razor blade glide effortlessly with each pass.

Because Taylor of Old Bond Street has been around since 1854, all of their products work incredibly well for sensitive skin. So, if you suffer from ingrown hairs, this shave cream is a step in the right direction for a long-lasting post-shave comfort.


  • A truly exceptional cream that has withstood the test of time 
  • An old favorite among wet shavers around the world
  • Prevents post-shave skin irritation


  • Does require a shave brush for even distribution
  • Users complain that this product smells of an old lady’s floral perfume
  • There are numerous complaints of opened boxes that the company needs to address soon 

5.Truefitt & Hill

Truefitt & Hill’s shaving cream has been developed especially for men with sensitive skin. The company has been making wet shaving products for over two centuries now. We must admit that Truefitt & Hill’s skin care products are the crème de la crème of the wet shaving world. The product that we bring to your attention is the Rolls Royce of shave creams, and has price tag to match.

Truefitt & Hill have smartly avoided any additional fragrances in their product. No matter if you have sensitive skin or not, you won’t expose your face to unnecessary chemicals before shaving.  If you have a favorite cologne or body spray, this shave cream will not start a fragrance conflict with it. Truefitt & Hill will also help if you have acne-prone skin. It’s natural soothing properties make this product suitable for all skin types.

Young men who have occasional acne rashes recommend Truefitt & Hill’s beard lube for a safe and close shave. This shave cream creates homogenic but at the same time light lather that won’t clog the pores of your skin. Had it not been for its high price, this would have been one of the best shaving creams for sensitive skin on the market!

Unfortunately, it’s a bit difficult to find this supreme product in stores. You can check out the boutique barber shops in Paris, Rome, or Seville though. This is the one shave cream that men are excited to use whenever they have the chance ti.  Once you try it, you never want to go back to your old shave gel.


  • A shave cream that of exceptional quality with minimum fragrance
  • Creates a slick protective layer between your skin and the blade
  • Suitable for wet shavers with mild acne


  • It’s rather expensive
  • Some users get turned off by the strange green appearance of the lather

6.Eos Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin

Eos Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin provides a smooth shave and reduces razor-induced irritation. This makes the product so popular with female wet shavers. If you have even the slightest of doubts regarding the soothing qualities of this product, just give it a try.

Every time you shave your legs and armpits, you’ll experience a sensational feeling of relief and comfort that no mainstream cream or gel can give you. The guys from eos give their female worshipers the comfort that they promise.

This shaving cream is especially suitable for female users with sensitive legs, armpits, and bikini zones. The unique soothing effect is created by the unique combination of three ingredients – aloe, oats, and lavender butter. Being a high-quality shaving cream, this product doesn’t have any added fragrance.

Many female safety razor users don’t mind a bit of a scent. However, other girls get nauseous just thinking about it. If you are of the latter kind, consider picking up a bottle of this cream. The eos Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin is so gentle that women have shared online that they do not need any post-shave lotion with it.


  • No razor burn or irritation even without moisturizer
  • Affordable price
  • No added fragrance


  • The creamy texture may turn down some users
  • Other users share, however, that it does not create enough foam
  • Ladies have also complained of frequent razor clogging

Shaving Cream FAQs

Here are some frequently asked questions about the best shaving creams for sensitive skin that need to we’ll try to answer in the paragraphs below.

1. Is shaving cream good for sensitive skin?

Yes, it is. In fact, it’s way better than any other beard lube.

2. Which is the best shaving cream?

It’s Jack Black Triple Cushion. This product has earned the top spot on our list because of the unique balance between price and value that it offers.

3. Which is better shaving cream or gel?

Shaving gels don’t lather up like high-quality shaving cream. They can’t be applied with a shaving brush so the hairs don’t get lifted up for a really close shave.

4. What is the best women’s shaving cream?

tThe Eos Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin has been developed by women for women. This product has got proven soothing qualities and will leave even the most pretentious ladies perfectly satisfied.

5. Should you use a shaving brush?

Even the best shave creams cannot create the smooth and even shave base that we mentioned above without a high-quality shave brush. Most men with sensitive skin sooner or later decide to invest in a quality shave lube, but overlook the importance of the shave brush. Shave brushes are designed to draw out the best properties of the shave creams.

Spreading the best shaving cream onto your face with the best brush is a truly divine experience. The contact between the brush and your beard makes the hairs stand upright and ready to meet the blade. By contrast, if beard lube is applied with bare hands, the whiskers get matted down.

The good partnership between the shaving cream and the brush reduces the number of passes. The fewer passes you have to make, the better your sensitive skin is going to feel.

6. Should You Use Shaving Oil?

One product we highly recommend to men with sensitive skin is shaving oil. It works in a partnership with the shave cream to create an excellent base for a safe shave. Adding a drop or two of shaving oil before the shave mitigates the impact that the razor blade on your sensitive skin. When choosing a pre-shave oil, stick to oils with 100% natural ingredients like Lather & Wood. 

What’s the biggest advantage of artisan shave products?

Unlike your cheap shave gel, the best shaving creams like Truefitt & Hill or Taylor of Old Bond can be whipped up into a thick and creamy lather that your razor can easily glide on. The best shaving creams reviewed below all have an outstanding level of lubrication that makes every pass of the blade feel like summer breeze.

A rich lube offered by all of the best shaving creams insulates your skin from the blade during the shave process, keeping your sensitive skin warm, and the hairs – soft. By contrast, a cheap shave lube creates a poor shaving environment. Their lather is full of air pockets and the razor struggles to get a clean cut on the hair.

Are there any anti-acne shaving creams?

Wet shaving with a safety razor is good even for teenagers struggling with acne, because there are some great anti-comedo shave creams. We’ve found out that the Truefitt & Hill shaving cream is the best for young men who don’t want to exacerbate their acne issues after every shave. These shaving creams for sensitive skin rinse off easily to ensure that your pores are absolutely clean.


When it comes to shaving creams for sensitive skin, quality becomes a key factor. These superior products do not rely on chemicals or synthetic ingredients for a better scent. Ingredients like these can lead to unwanted irritation.

On the other hand, natural ingredients create in the user a sense of natural comfort. Therefore, brands like Jack Black, Taylor of Old Bond Street, and Truefitt & Hill are in every man’s dreams. If you are looking for a great way to start your day, give one of the beard lubes above a try!

Win a Merkur Futur Worth $60!

Merkur Futur Review